drjones/astraea
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Astraea v1.0 — multi-agent WA family-law assistant

Browse Source 
Eight specialist agents over a 16-book verified WA law corpus (RAG with citations),
per-user document vault, WA court-form PDF auto-fill, comms missions with DV
safety guard, no-KYC auth, TTS. Self-hosted: Flask + SQLite + Ollama, stdlib-only RAG.

Includes README, LICENSE (MIT + not-legal-advice notice), DEPLOY runbook, .gitignore.
This commit is contained in:
drjones
2026-09-07 18:49:32 -07:00
commit 9f9d812320
37 changed files with 4934 additions and 0 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

98
books/modification-enforcement.md Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,98 @@
For educational purposes only — not legal advice.
# Modifying and Enforcing Washington Family Law Orders
This book is for Washington State residents who already have final orders — a divorce decree, parenting plan, child support order, or spousal maintenance (alimony) order — and need to change one or make the other side follow it. Every statute cite was verified September 2026 against the official text at app.leg.wa.gov.
## Modifying a parenting plan
A parenting plan is a court order and cannot be changed just because you are unhappy with it. The court may not modify a parenting plan unless it finds, based on facts that arose after the plan was entered (or were unknown to the court then), that (a) a **substantial change has occurred in the circumstances of the child or the nonmoving parent**, and (b) the modification is **in the best interest of the child and necessary** to serve that interest (RCW 26.09.260(1)). A parent's military duties alone are not a substantial change (RCW 26.09.260(1)).
Even with changed circumstances, the court **keeps the existing residential schedule** unless one of four things is shown (RCW 26.09.260(2)):
1. The **parents agree**;
2. The child has been **integrated into the moving parent's family with the other parent's consent**, in substantial deviation from the plan;
3. The child's **present environment is detrimental** to the child's physical, mental, or emotional health, and the harm of a change is outweighed by its advantage to the child; or
4. The nonmoving parent has been found **in contempt at least twice within three years** for failing the residential provisions, or has been **convicted of custodial interference**.
A custodial interference conviction (RCW 9A.40.060 or 9A.40.070) is itself a substantial change of circumstances (RCW 26.09.260(3)). The court may also reduce or restrict a parent's contact using the limitation criteria in RCW 26.09.191 and 26.09.192 (RCW 26.09.260(4)).
### Minor modifications and nonresidential changes
Smaller changes are easier. The court may make a **minor modification** to the residential schedule — one that does not change which parent the child lives with most of the time — on a substantial change in circumstances of **either parent or the child**, without the stricter factors above, if the change (RCW 26.09.260(5)): does not exceed **24 full days per calendar year**; results from the **non-primary parent moving** or an **involuntary work-schedule change** that makes the plan impractical; or adds up to no more than **90 overnights per year** when the plan does not give the non-primary parent reasonable time. A move by the parent the child lives with most is not a "minor modification" — that triggers the relocation rules below. Guardrails: a parent restricted under RCW 26.09.191 or 26.09.192 must show a change specifically related to the limitation (RCW 26.09.260(7)); a repeat 90-overnight motion within 24 months faces the stricter factors (RCW 26.09.260(5)); and a parent who has not completed court-ordered evaluations, treatment, or classes cannot expand time (RCW 26.09.260(9)). **Nonresidential aspects** of the plan (decision-making, dispute resolution) can be adjusted on a substantial change plus the child's best interest (RCW 26.09.260(10)). A **bad-faith motion** can cost the moving party the other parent's attorney fees and costs (RCW 26.09.260(13)).
### The "adequate cause" gate and venue
A party seeking to modify must submit an **affidavit setting forth facts** supporting the change; the court **denies the motion unless the affidavits establish "adequate cause"** for a hearing (RCW 26.09.270). The action may be filed in the county where the children live, the court that entered the order, or the county where the custodial parent lives (RCW 26.09.280).
## Modifying child support
A party may petition for child support modification based on **substantially changed circumstances at any time** (RCW 26.09.170(5)(a)). Two limits matter: modification applies **only to installments accruing after the petition** — no retroactive change (RCW 26.09.170(1)(a)) — and **voluntary unemployment or underemployment alone is not a substantial change** (RCW 26.09.170(5)(b)); a parent who quits or takes a voluntary pay cut may still have income imputed under the support schedule.
Some modifications skip the changed-circumstances requirement:
- **After one year**, an order may be modified without it for **severe economic hardship**, to extend support for a child still in high school past 18, or to add an **automatic adjustment** provision (RCW 26.09.170(8)).
- **After 24 months** from entry or the last adjustment, either party may seek adjustment based on **changed incomes or changes to the schedule's economic table**, by motion and worksheets (RCW 26.09.170(9)). A change over 30% causing significant hardship may be phased in two six-month steps (RCW 26.09.170(9)(c)).
- An order may be modified to add **incarceration abatement** (support reduced to $10 per month during confinement of six months or more) and again on release, without changed circumstances (RCW 26.09.170(6)–(7); RCW 26.09.320).
- **DCS** may seek modification when public assistance is paid or a review is requested, using a 15% deviation threshold (RCW 26.09.170(10)–(11)).
**Procedure.** Modification begins with a **petition and worksheets**; the filing fee is $20 (RCW 26.09.175(1)). The response is due in **20 days** (60 days out of state) or default judgment follows (RCW 26.09.175(4)). The case is normally decided **on affidavits and worksheets alone**; oral testimony requires extraordinary circumstances, and testimony may be remote (RCW 26.09.175(6)–(8)). The decree itself may require **automatic periodic adjustments** (RCW 26.09.100), and the support schedule applies in every modification proceeding (RCW 26.19.035(1), (3)).
## Modifying spousal maintenance
Maintenance is harder to change than child support. A decree respecting maintenance may be modified **only as to installments accruing after the petition** and **only on a showing of a substantial change of circumstances** (RCW 26.09.170(1)). The **property division** may not be modified at all unless conditions exist that would justify reopening a judgment — rare (RCW 26.09.170(1)). Maintenance **ends automatically** on the death of either party, or on the recipient's remarriage or registration of a new domestic partnership, unless the decree or a written agreement says otherwise (RCW 26.09.170(2)). Cohabitation with a new partner is not, by statute, a termination event.
## What is a "substantial change of circumstances"?
It means something real and meaningful that has happened since the order. The statutory anchors: for **parenting plans**, a substantial change in the circumstances of the **child or the nonmoving parent** (RCW 26.09.260(1)); for **maintenance**, a substantial change judged against what the court contemplated when it made the award (RCW 26.09.170(1)(b)); for **child support**, "substantially changed circumstances" — with the carve-out that voluntary unemployment or underemployment alone does not qualify (RCW 26.09.170(5)) and the one-year and 24-month paths that skip the requirement (RCW 26.09.170(8)–(9)). In practice, qualifying changes are usually significant income changes, a parent's move, a child's changing needs, or a serious problem in the child's environment.
## Relocation: when a move triggers modification
Washington's relocation scheme, RCW 26.09.405 through 26.09.560, applies to plans entered after June 8, 2000, and older orders silent on relocation (RCW 26.09.405). "Relocate" means a change in the child's principal residence, permanent or protracted (RCW 26.09.410).
**Notice.** A parent with majority residential time — or either parent in a substantially equal-time arrangement — must notify everyone entitled to residential time of an intended relocation (RCW 26.09.430). Notice is by personal service or return-receipt mail, at least **60 days before the move** (or within 5 days of learning the needed information), with specific reasons and a statutory warning that an objection must be filed within **30 days** or the move will be permitted (RCW 26.09.440). Failure to give notice is grounds for **sanctions, including contempt** (RCW 26.09.470).
**Objecting.** The other parent files a petition to modify the parenting plan (or another adequate proceeding) within 30 days, plus a three-day mail waiting period (RCW 26.09.480(1)). Once an objection is filed, the relocating parent generally **may not move the child** without a court order, and a hearing noticed within 15 days freezes the move (RCW 26.09.480(2)). If no one objects in time, the relocation is **permitted** (except for good cause) and the proposed revised schedule takes effect (RCW 26.09.500).
**The presumption.** There is a **rebuttable presumption the relocation will be permitted**; the objecting parent must show the move's detrimental effect outweighs its benefit to the child and the relocating person under eleven unweighted factors (RCW 26.09.520). But where parents have **substantially equal residential time** — 45% or more of the child's time with each parent — **there is no presumption**; the court decides in the child's best interests using the same factors (RCW 26.09.525). Relocation or objections made to harass or run up costs can draw **sanctions** (RCW 26.09.550); relocation hearings get docket priority (RCW 26.09.560).
**The modification hook.** A relocation dispute is itself a modification pathway: either parent may petition to modify the plan — including changing the child's primary residence — **without showing adequate cause other than the proposed relocation itself**. The court first decides whether to permit or restrain the move, then what change to make to the plan (RCW 26.09.260(6)).
## Enforcing parenting plans: contempt
If the other parent violates the plan, the remedy is a **contempt action**. Self-help is barred: one parent's violation does **not suspend** the other's obligations, and conditioning support on residential time is bad faith (RCW 26.09.160(1)). A parent who in bad faith fails to comply with residential provisions faces (RCW 26.09.160(2)):
- **Make-up time** equal to the time missed;
- Payment of the other parent's **court costs and reasonable attorney fees**;
- A **civil penalty of at least $100**;
- **Jail up to 180 days**, but only if the parent is presently **able** to comply and presently **unwilling**.
A **second violation within three years** doubles the make-up time and raises the penalty to at least $250 (RCW 26.09.160(3)). Present ability to comply is **presumed**; the accused parent must prove inability or a reasonable excuse by a preponderance of the evidence (RCW 26.09.160(4)). Monetary awards are collected like civil judgments (RCW 26.09.160(5)).
## Enforcing support: contempt and continuing jurisdiction
A parent who fails to pay support or maintenance faces a contempt action under chapter 7.21 RCW: petition or motion, order to show cause, and — if warned and absent — a **bench warrant** (RCW 26.18.050(1)–(3)). A parent claiming inability to pay must prove **due diligence** in seeking employment or otherwise becoming able to comply (RCW 26.18.050(4)). The court **retains continuing jurisdiction** to enforce until **all arrearages are paid** — arrears do not vanish when the child turns 18 (RCW 26.18.050(5)).
## Income withholding
Support is normally paid by automatic **income withholding**. A wage-assignment or income-withholding order is available if the support order allows immediate withholding, or if the payer is **more than 15 days past due in an amount of at least one month's obligation** (RCW 26.18.070(1)). The court directs the order to the employer and the clerk forwards it to the **Washington State Support Registry** within five days (RCW 26.18.080). Support orders must state that withholding may be taken against wages, earnings, assets, or benefits without further notice (RCW 26.23.050). A withholding order can be quashed or modified only for **extreme hardship or substantial injustice**; after 12 consecutive months of current payments the payer may move to terminate it unless the recipient shows good cause (RCW 26.18.140).
## Division of Child Support (DCS)
The **Division of Child Support (DCS)** runs the State Support Registry and must provide enforcement services whenever public assistance is paid, whenever a parent applies, or when payments route through the registry (RCW 26.23.045(1)). Services continue until a court orders payments out of the registry (RCW 26.23.045(2)). DCS has administrative enforcement tools beyond court process and can also seek modification in court (RCW 26.09.170(10)–(11)).
## License suspension for unpaid child support
If a parent falls out of compliance, DCS may serve a **notice of noncompliance** with intent to suspend licenses (RCW 74.20A.320(1)). The parent has **20 days** to: pay the arrears in full; request an administrative hearing (RCW 74.20A.322); arrange a payment schedule (RCW 74.20A.326); or **file a court action to modify support**, which stays suspension up to six months (RCW 74.20A.320(2)(b)). Otherwise DCS certifies noncompliance to the Department of Licensing and other agencies, and the parent's **driver's license — plus fishing, hunting, and occupational licenses — is suspended or not renewed** until DCS issues a release (RCW 74.20A.320(2)(c)). Support orders must warn that licenses may be suspended for noncompliance (RCW 26.23.050).
## Interest on unpaid support
Judgments for unpaid child support bear **12% interest** (RCW 4.56.110(2)), and DCS may assess **12% per year** on unpaid support accrued under registry orders, unless the order specifies a different rate (RCW 26.23.030(2)).
## Deadlines, back pay, and time limits
- **No back pay.** Modification applies only to installments accruing after the petition or motion (RCW 26.09.170(1)(a)) — so file promptly, and note the duty to pay is not suspended by the other side's misconduct (RCW 26.09.160(1)).
- **No waiting period to modify.** Child support modification may be sought "at any time" (RCW 26.09.170(5)(a)); parenting plan modification has no fixed waiting period but must pass the adequate-cause gate (RCW 26.09.270). The one-year and 24-month windows only concern modifications made *without* proving changed circumstances (RCW 26.09.170(8)–(9)).
- **Child support arrears last longest.** Collection may be brought within **10 years of the youngest child's 18th birthday** (RCW 4.16.020(3)), with execution available in that window (RCW 6.17.020(2)) — extendable in 10-year increments (RCW 6.17.020(3)).
- **Other judgments — including maintenance arrearages** — are generally enforceable for **10 years from entry**, renewable for another 10 by application within 90 days before expiration, granted as a matter of right (RCW 6.17.020(1), (3); RCW 4.16.020(2)). No judgment is enforceable beyond 20 years from entry except as provided in RCW 4.16.020(2) or (3) (RCW 6.17.020(7)).
- **Relocation deadlines are strict.** The 60-day notice and 30-day objection clocks bind; missing the objection deadline can mean the move is permitted and the proposed schedule takes effect (RCW 26.09.440; RCW 26.09.500).